In 1991 India faced an economic crisis: a high fiscal deficit, a severe balance of payments problem, very low foreign exchange reserves (enough for only about two weeks of imports), rising prices, and a fall in foreign borrowing ability. Earlier policies had led to inefficiency of the public sector and slow growth. So India introduced reforms (the New Economic Policy) to stabilise the economy and make it more efficient and competitive.
Ch 3 · Liberalisation, privatisation and globalisation: an appraisal
Exercises
Exercises
Membership of the WTO helps a country trade freely with other member countries without discrimination; it gives access to world markets, helps settle trade disputes through a rules-based system, and allows the country to take part in framing global trade rules. Remaining outside would isolate a country from world trade.
Earlier the RBI fixed interest rates, decided reserve requirements and controlled credit tightly. After the reforms, banks were allowed to take many decisions themselves (interest rates, branches, etc.), and private and foreign banks were allowed. So the RBI's role changed from controller to facilitator — creating a healthy environment and regulating with lighter touch to encourage competition and efficiency.
Through quantitative tools like the Cash Reserve Ratio (CRR), Statutory Liquidity Ratio (SLR), bank rate, repo and reverse repo rates and open market operations; and through qualitative tools like moral suasion, margin requirements and selective credit control. It also supervises and regulates banks.
Devaluation is a deliberate lowering of the value of the domestic currency (rupee) in terms of foreign currencies by the government. In 1991 the rupee was devalued to increase exports and reduce imports, to correct the balance of payments.
- (i) Strategic and Minority sale
- (ii) Bilateral and Multi-lateral trade
- (iii) Tariff and Non-tariff barriers.
(i) Strategic sale: transfer of a large share (usually majority) of a public sector unit to a private party along with management control. Minority sale: sale of a small portion of shares to the public, the government keeping control.
(ii) Bilateral trade: trade agreements between two countries. Multilateral trade: trade under agreements among many countries (e.g. under the WTO).
(iii) Tariff barriers: taxes (duties) on imports/exports. Non-tariff barriers: restrictions other than taxes, such as quotas, licences and quality standards.
Tariffs are imposed to make imported goods costlier and so protect domestic industries from foreign competition, to discourage imports of certain goods, to earn revenue for the government and to correct the balance of payments.
Quantitative restrictions are limits on the quantity of goods that can be imported or exported (quotas), regardless of their price.
Not entirely. Profit-making PSUs earn revenue for the government and some serve strategic and social objectives, so they need not be privatised; instead they can be given more autonomy (as Navratnas) to improve efficiency. Privatisation may be better for loss-making units. (Answers may argue either way with reasons.)
Yes, outsourcing is good for India: it creates jobs (BPOs, IT services), brings foreign exchange and develops skills. Developed countries oppose it because jobs and income move from their country to countries like India, causing unemployment there.
A large pool of skilled, English-speaking, educated and technically trained workers; low wage costs; good communication and IT infrastructure; time-zone advantage (working while the West sleeps); and supportive government policies.
How?
Yes. The Navaratna (and Maharatna/Miniratna) policy gave selected profitable PSUs greater managerial and financial autonomy to expand, form joint ventures and compete globally. This improved their efficiency, profits and market share, though full autonomy is not always given in practice.
Growth of IT and IT-enabled services, banking, finance, insurance and telecom; outsourcing; liberalisation and entry of private and foreign firms; rising incomes and urbanisation increasing demand for services; and a skilled workforce.
Public investment in agriculture (irrigation, power, roads, research) declined; fertiliser subsidies were reduced, raising costs; import duties on farm products were lowered, increasing competition from cheaper imports; and there was a shift towards cash crops for export instead of food grains. Small farmers faced more risk and lower incomes.
Cheaper imports reduced demand for domestic industrial goods; investment in infrastructure (especially power) was inadequate; developed countries kept non-tariff barriers against Indian goods; and global competition was intense for Indian firms used to protection.
The reforms raised the growth rate, foreign exchange reserves and exports, and benefited the services sector and urban, educated people. But the benefits were not evenly spread: agriculture and small industries suffered, employment growth was slow, inequality between regions and groups increased, and public spending on social sectors was reduced — so the reforms have not done enough for social justice and welfare.