Photosynthesis in Higher Plants
C3 vs C4 Plants & Anatomy
1. By looking at a plant externally, can you tell whether a plant is C3 or C4?
Generally, No. It is difficult to distinguish C3 and C4 plants purely by external appearance.
However: C4 plants are adapted to dry tropical regions. If a plant is thriving in very hot, dry conditions (like Maize, Sorghum, Sugarcane) without wilting, it is likely a C4 plant. But this is not a definitive test without examining internal anatomy.
2. By looking at which internal structure can you tell if a plant is C3 or C4?
You can tell by observing the Leaf Anatomy (Transverse Section).
– Presence of large Bundle Sheath cells arranged in a wreath-like manner around vascular bundles.
– Bundle sheath cells have large numbers of chloroplasts, thick walls impervious to gases, and no intercellular spaces.
C3 Plants:
– Lack this specific arrangement (No Kranz anatomy). Bundle sheath cells are present but not differentiated in the Kranz pattern.
3. Why are C4 plants highly productive despite few cells carrying out the Calvin cycle?
C4 plants are more productive because:
- CO2 Concentrating Mechanism: The mesophyll cells pump $CO_2$ (as malic acid) into the bundle sheath cells. This keeps the intracellular $CO_2$ concentration very high at the site of RuBisCO.
- Prevention of Photorespiration: High $CO_2$ ensures RuBisCO acts only as a carboxylase (fixing carbon) and not as an oxygenase. This prevents the wasteful process of photorespiration.
- Efficiency: They can tolerate higher temperatures and high light intensity.
4. Why does RuBisCO carry out more carboxylation in C4 plants?
RuBisCO has an active site that can bind to both $CO_2$ and $O_2$. Its activity depends on the relative concentration of these gases.
In C4 plants, the unique C4 pathway (Hatch & Slack pathway) actively transports $CO_2$ from mesophyll cells to bundle sheath cells. This creates a locally high concentration of $CO_2$ around the enzyme RuBisCO. This high $CO_2:O_2$ ratio forces the enzyme to function purely as a carboxylase, minimizing oxygenase activity.
Pigments, Light & Adaptation
5. Can plants with high Chl b but no Chl a photosynthesize?
No. They would not be able to carry out photosynthesis.
- Chlorophyll a is the primary pigment and forms the Reaction Centre where the primary photochemical reaction (ejection of electron) occurs.
- Role of Accessory Pigments (Chl b, Xanthophylls, Carotenoids):
- They absorb light at different wavelengths and transfer the energy to Chlorophyll a.
- They protect Chlorophyll a from photo-oxidation.
6. Why do leaves in the dark become yellow? Which pigment is more stable?
Yellowing (Etiolation): In the absence of light, plants cannot synthesize new Chlorophyll, and existing Chlorophyll degrades. The yellow/orange pigments (Carotenoids) are unmasked.
Stability: Carotenoids are more stable than Chlorophyll. They do not degrade as quickly in the absence of light, which is why the leaf appears yellow.
7. Shade leaves vs Sun leaves: Which are darker green?
Shade Leaves (or plants in shade) are Darker Green.
Reason: Plants adapt to low light intensity by increasing the amount of chlorophyll and the size of chloroplasts to maximize light absorption. Leaves in direct sunlight often have thicker cuticles and less chlorophyll per surface area to prevent photo-oxidation, appearing lighter green.
8. Analysis of Light Intensity Graph (Fig 11.10).
- (a) Light is limiting: At Region A (the linear part of the curve) and partially at B. Here, increasing light increases the rate.
- (b) Limiting factors in A: Only Light Intensity is the limiting factor because the rate is directly proportional to it.
- (c) C and D:
- C: Represents the point where light saturation is approached.
- D: Represents the maximum rate (saturation) where light is no longer limiting. Other factors (like $CO_2$ concentration or Temperature) have become limiting.
Comparisons
9. (a) Comparison: C3 and C4 Pathways.
| Feature | C3 Pathway | C4 Pathway |
|---|---|---|
| Primary CO2 Acceptor | RuBP (5-carbon) | PEP (3-carbon) |
| Primary Product | PGA (3-carbon) | OAA (4-carbon) |
| Site of Carboxylation | Mesophyll | Mesophyll (PEP) & Bundle Sheath (RuBisCO) |
| Kranz Anatomy | Absent | Present |
| Photorespiration | Present (Wasteful) | Absent (Efficient) |
| Optimum Temp | Low (20-25°C) | High (30-40°C) |
9. (b) Comparison: Cyclic and Non-cyclic Photophosphorylation.
| Feature | Cyclic | Non-Cyclic |
|---|---|---|
| Photosystems | Only PS I functions. | Both PS I and PS II function. |
| Electron Flow | Cyclic (returns to PS I). | Non-cyclic (H2O $\to$ PS II $\to$ PS I $\to$ NADP). |
| Products | Only ATP. | ATP and NADPH + $H^+$. |
| Photolysis of Water | Absent. | Present (Oxygen evolved). |
9. (c) Comparison: Anatomy of Leaf in C3 and C4.
| Feature | C3 Leaf | C4 Leaf |
|---|---|---|
| Bundle Sheath Cells | Present but not specialized. | Specialized, large, thick-walled (Kranz Anatomy). |
| Chloroplasts | One type (in mesophyll). | Dimorphic (Granal in mesophyll, Agranal in bundle sheath). |
| Intercellular Spaces | Present. | Absent in bundle sheath region. |